Compare / Agency vs a social media manager
Hire a social media manager, or an agency?
A full time hire gives you one person in your building. An agency gives you a team for a monthly fee. Here’s an honest look at both, including when hiring makes more sense.
Side by side
| Compare | Shock Social | A full time hire |
|---|---|---|
| Who does the work | A strategist, script writer, videographers, editors, and community managers | One person covering every skill |
| Monthly cost | From $470 a month without filming, $740 with filming. No setup fees. | A full time salary, plus payroll taxes, benefits, and paid time off |
| Gear and software | Cameras, lighting, audio, editing, and scheduling tools included | Bought and paid for by you |
| Filming and editing | On site shoot days with our crew, or scripts for you to film | Depends on whether your hire films and edits well |
| Getting started | Starts with research and a content calendar | Starts with recruiting, interviews, and training |
| If someone is out | The rest of the team keeps your posts going | Posting stops until they’re back |
| Day to day presence | Shoot days and calls, not in your office every day | In your building for same day moments |
| Best for | Businesses that want the full system without building a department | Larger teams posting daily who need someone on site full time |
The short version
- A hire gives you one person, and you manage them.
- An agency gives you a whole team for a monthly fee, with no hiring or training.
- Our packages start at $470 a month, published on our pricing page.
- A hire is better when you need someone in the building every day.
What to weigh
One salary buys one skill set
Good social media takes research, writing, filming, editing, design, posting, and replying. It’s rare to find one person who is strong at all of them. An agency splits that work across people who each do one part every day.
A hire costs more than the salary
On top of pay, there are payroll taxes, benefits, paid time off, software subscriptions, camera gear, and the time it takes to recruit and train. When a hire leaves, what they knew about your account often leaves with them.
What a hire does better
Someone on staff is in the room. They can catch a moment the same day, know your team by name, and post from every location daily. If that’s what your business needs, a full time hire can make sense.
The middle path
Some businesses keep a team member as the face on camera and the person who sends footage, and hand us the research, scripts, editing, posting, and replies. Our “you film” packages are built for exactly that.
Common questions
Is an agency cheaper than hiring a social media manager?
For most small businesses, yes. Our packages start at $470 a month without filming, $740 with filming, and they include gear, software, and a whole team. A full time hire costs a salary plus taxes, benefits, and tools.
Will an agency understand my business as well as an employee?
We start every month with research into your niche, you approve the calendar, and we meet you on shoot days. Every script is written in your first person voice.
Can we have a staff member and an agency?
Yes. Many clients keep someone in house as the on camera face or coordinator while we handle strategy, scripts, editing, posting, and replies.
What happens if my contact at the agency is out?
Your account is run by a team, so posts and replies keep going.
See what a month would look like.
Start with a free content calendar for your business, or check our pricing.
